WikiHikmah

Main Page: Difference between revisions

← Older editNewer edit →
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 154: Line 154:
<br />
<br />
Whatever is real is, in principle, intelligible: it has some reason, ground, or explanation for why it is rather than is not, even if that ground is intrinsic rather than external, simple rather than composite, or presently unknown to us. This minimal form of the Principle of Sufficient Reason does not assume that every explanation is easy, exhaustive, or immediately accessible. It asserts only that reality is not brute chaos. To affirm intelligibility is to affirm that existence is not finally resistant to reason, even where human understanding remains partial, provisional, or domain-limited.
Whatever is real is, in principle, intelligible: it has some reason, ground, or explanation for why it is rather than is not, even if that ground is intrinsic rather than external, simple rather than composite, or presently unknown to us. This minimal form of the Principle of Sufficient Reason does not assume that every explanation is easy, exhaustive, or immediately accessible. It asserts only that reality is not brute chaos. To affirm intelligibility is to affirm that existence is not finally resistant to reason, even where human understanding remains partial, provisional, or domain-limited.
The demand that reality, events, beliefs, and claims be accountable to explanation rather than accepted as brute assertion.
Explanation; cause; ground; reason why; sufficient reason; causal order; intelligible ground; account; ''ʿillah''.


=== 4. Contingency and Dependent Existence ===
=== 4. Contingency and Dependent Existence ===
Line 172: Line 175:
<br />
<br />
This disposition is the willingness to subordinate psychological ease, inherited familiarity, social approval, and personal convenience to what one has best reason to judge true. It entails a principled resistance to self-deception, motivated reasoning, sentimental attachment to falsehood, and the refusal to revise one’s position when evidence or argument requires it. Without such a preference, reason becomes merely instrumental: a tool for decorating prior loyalties rather than correcting them. Preference for truth over comfort is therefore the first moral discipline of the intellect, and the condition of all genuine intellectual integrity.
This disposition is the willingness to subordinate psychological ease, inherited familiarity, social approval, and personal convenience to what one has best reason to judge true. It entails a principled resistance to self-deception, motivated reasoning, sentimental attachment to falsehood, and the refusal to revise one’s position when evidence or argument requires it. Without such a preference, reason becomes merely instrumental: a tool for decorating prior loyalties rather than correcting them. Preference for truth over comfort is therefore the first moral discipline of the intellect, and the condition of all genuine intellectual integrity.
'''Epistemic responsibility'''
The obligation to proportion belief, action, and authority to truth, evidence, reasoning, and the limits of knowledge.
Intellectual honesty; sincerity; ''ikhlāṣ''; trustworthiness; verification; discipline; humility; evidence; accountability.


=== 2. Self-Cultivation ===
=== 2. Self-Cultivation ===
Line 200: Line 206:
Rationalist Islam proceeds on the principle that no claim is exempt from reason’s jurisdiction. Every position is derived — not asserted — by applying the Five Prior Rational Commitments. What follows is a continuous sequence of conclusions that any rational agent should grant once those priors are accepted.
Rationalist Islam proceeds on the principle that no claim is exempt from reason’s jurisdiction. Every position is derived — not asserted — by applying the Five Prior Rational Commitments. What follows is a continuous sequence of conclusions that any rational agent should grant once those priors are accepted.


=== Entailment sequence ===


The following sequence is a synoptic presentation. Each entry is intended to link to a fuller article in which the concept, historical sources, comparative vocabulary, objections, and implications are treated in greater detail.






'''Self-awareness'''
'''Hierarchy of faculties'''
The reflexive recognition that consciousness is not only aware of objects, but also aware of itself as the subject of experience.
The ordering of appetite, emotion, imagination, will, and reason according to the governing role of intellect.
Self-knowledge; reflexivity; introspection; witnessing self; knowing soul; ''gnōthi seauton''; ''maʿrifat al-nafs''.
Tripartite soul; rational soul; self-mastery; discipline; ''nafs''; ''qalb''; ''ʿaql''; charioteer; inner kingdom.
 
 
'''Primacy of intellect'''
The claim that intellect is the governing faculty through which truth, value, revelation, selfhood, and order are rightly apprehended.
 
 
''ʿAql''; ''nous''; wisdom; intellect; higher mind; buddhi; reason; logos; noetic faculty; light of intelligence.
 
===26) Superiority / sovereignty of intellect===
 
 
'''Reason'''
The faculty by which distinctions, relations, contradictions, causes, and implications are apprehended.
Reason; ratio; logos; intellect; understanding; discernment; ''ʿaql''; ''nous''; buddhi; wisdom-mind.




Line 221: Line 239:




'''Reason'''
===1) Metaphysical rationalism===
The faculty by which distinctions, relations, contradictions, causes, and implications are apprehended.
 
Reason; ratio; logos; intellect; understanding; discernment; ''ʿaql''; ''nous''; buddhi; wisdom-mind.
===2) Foundationalism===


===3) Epistemic parsimony===


'''Principle of sufficient reason'''
===4) Ontological parsimony===
The demand that reality, events, beliefs, and claims be accountable to explanation rather than accepted as brute assertion.
Explanation; cause; ground; reason why; sufficient reason; causal order; intelligible ground; account; ''ʿillah''.
===5) Primacy of [[Consciousness]]===


Awareness • Inner Light • Knowing Presence • Mind • Nafs • Presence • Psyche • Rūḥ • Sentience • Shahadah • Spirit • Subjectivity • Witnessing
 
The immediate field of awareness in which experience, knowledge, doubt, perception, selfhood, and inquiry appear.


'''Epistemic responsibility'''
===6) Analytic idealism===
The obligation to proportion belief, action, and authority to truth, evidence, reasoning, and the limits of knowledge.
Intellectual honesty; sincerity; ''ikhlāṣ''; trustworthiness; verification; discipline; humility; evidence; accountability.


===7) Oneness of consciousness===


'''Hierarchy of faculties'''
Monism • Nondualism
The ordering of appetite, emotion, imagination, will, and reason according to the governing role of intellect.
Tripartite soul; rational soul; self-mastery; discipline; ''nafs''; ''qalb''; ''ʿaql''; charioteer; inner kingdom.


===8) Ontological priority===


'''Primacy of intellect'''
===9) Gradation of consciousness===
The claim that intellect is the governing faculty through which truth, value, revelation, selfhood, and order are rightly apprehended.


Gradation of existence • Gradation of reality • Tashkīk al-wujūd


''ʿAql''; ''nous''; wisdom; intellect; higher mind; buddhi; reason; logos; noetic faculty; light of intelligence.
===10) Meta Consciousness===


Ahura Mazda • Allāh • Aten • Baha • Brahman • Dao • 'Ēl • Father • God • God the Father • Necessary Existent • Necessary Existentiator • Necessary Reality • Pure Consciousness • Shangdi • Tao • The Divine • The One • Unconditioned Reality • Vishnu • Waheguru • Wājib al-Wujūd • Yahweh


'''Meta-Consciousness'''
'''Meta-Consciousness'''
Line 252: Line 273:
Ahura Mazda; Allāh; Aten; Bahā; Brahman; Dao; Ēl; Father; God; God the Father; Necessary Existent; Necessary Existentiator; Necessary Reality; Pure Consciousness; Shangdi; Tao; The Divine; The One; Unconditioned Reality; Vishnu; Waheguru; Wājib al-Wujūd; Yahweh.
Ahura Mazda; Allāh; Aten; Bahā; Brahman; Dao; Ēl; Father; God; God the Father; Necessary Existent; Necessary Existentiator; Necessary Reality; Pure Consciousness; Shangdi; Tao; The Divine; The One; Unconditioned Reality; Vishnu; Waheguru; Wājib al-Wujūd; Yahweh.


===11) Necessary simplicity===
Al-Basāṭah al-ilāhiyyah • Divine simplicity • Monotheism • Oneness • Oneness of Allah • Oneness of God • Tawhīd
===12) Absolute necessary simplicity===
===13) Conscientiation ex conscientia===
Badā'a • Creatio ex deo • Origination


'''Creation and emanation'''
'''Creation and emanation'''
The dependence of contingent reality upon the necessary ground, expressed through creation, emanation, manifestation, or unfolding.
The dependence of contingent reality upon the necessary ground, expressed through creation, emanation, manifestation, or unfolding.
Creation; emanation; manifestation; effusion; procession; ''fayḍ''; ''tajallī''; logos; divine command; cosmic unfolding.
Creation; emanation; manifestation; effusion; procession; ''fayḍ''; ''tajallī''; logos; divine command; cosmic unfolding.
===14) Necessitarianism===
ʿAdl • Divine justice
===15) Eternalism / [[Eternal Creation]]===
===16) Rule of one===
===17) First conscientiate===
First creation • First intellect • First light • Image of God • Imago dei • Mashīyya • Nūr Muhammadiyya • Ontologically first dependent existent • Pen • Perfect creation • Qalam • Universal intellect
===18) Intermediary conscientiates===
Angels • Immaterial existents • Malāʾika
===19) Observable universe===
Cosmos • Dunyā • Material dimension • Material realm • Material world • Multiverse • Natural World • Olam HaZeh • Physical world • Sensible dimension • Sensible realm • Sensible world • Universe
===20) B-theory of time===
Tenseless theory of time
===21) Compatibilism===
Divine Decree • Divine Predestination • Illusion of Libertarian Free Will • Predestination • Qadar • Soft determinism
===22) Perdurantism===
===23) Physical empiricism===
Empirical method • Scientific method
'''Self-awareness'''
The reflexive recognition that consciousness is not only aware of objects, but also aware of itself as the subject of experience.
Self-knowledge; reflexivity; introspection; witnessing self; knowing soul; ''gnōthi seauton''; ''maʿrifat al-nafs''.




Line 261: Line 329:
The intelligible worth of beings, actions, states, and ends in relation to truth, flourishing, consciousness, and perfection.
The intelligible worth of beings, actions, states, and ends in relation to truth, flourishing, consciousness, and perfection.
Good; the Good; ''khayr''; beauty; justice; virtue; value; excellence; ''aretē''; ''iḥsān''; righteousness.
Good; the Good; ''khayr''; beauty; justice; virtue; value; excellence; ''aretē''; ''iḥsān''; righteousness.


'''Moral causality'''
'''Moral causality'''
Line 282: Line 349:
Stable excellence of character produced by the correct ordering of the self under intellect and oriented toward the good.
Stable excellence of character produced by the correct ordering of the self under intellect and oriented toward the good.
Virtue; ''faḍīlah''; ''aretē''; righteousness; nobility; excellence; ''iḥsān''; moral beauty; self-mastery.
Virtue; ''faḍīlah''; ''aretē''; righteousness; nobility; excellence; ''iḥsān''; moral beauty; self-mastery.




Line 298: Line 366:
Living word; guidance; movement; renewal; unfolding; interpretation; ''taʾwīl''; remembrance; divine pedagogy.
Living word; guidance; movement; renewal; unfolding; interpretation; ''taʾwīl''; remembrance; divine pedagogy.


===24) [[Mindfulness]]===
Dhikr • God consciousness • Meditation • Salāh • Taqwā
===25) Self-cultivation===
===27) Rational self-governance===
===28) Mysticism===
'Ibādah • Islām • Servitude • Submission • Worship
===29) Prayer===
Ṣalāh
===30) Fasting===
Ṣawm
===31) Charity===
Almsgiving • Zakāh
===32) Pilgrimage===
Ḥajj
===33) [[Resistance]]===


Discipline • Exertion • Fighting • Holy war • Jihād • Sacred battle • Striving • Struggle


'''Scripture'''
===34) Heightened consciousness===
The textual crystallisation of revelation, guidance, law, memory, and wisdom within a community.
 
Qurʾān; Torah; Gospel; Veda; Upanishad; scripture; book; word; law; guidance; covenant; remembrance.
Altered state of consciousness • Anubhava • Enlightenment • Henosis • Ilhām • Nirvana • Noetic mystical experience • Nubuwwah • Perfect knowledge acquisition • Prophethood • Samadhi • Revelation • Wahī
 
===35) Gradation of Intellect===


Cognitive heterogeneity




Line 309: Line 411:
The function by which higher guidance is embodied, communicated, and historically enacted through a transformed human agent.
The function by which higher guidance is embodied, communicated, and historically enacted through a transformed human agent.
Prophet; Nabī; Rasūl; Messenger; seer; sage; avatar; apostle; lawgiver; herald; teacher; divine envoy.
Prophet; Nabī; Rasūl; Messenger; seer; sage; avatar; apostle; lawgiver; herald; teacher; divine envoy.
'''Scripture'''
The textual crystallisation of revelation, guidance, law, memory, and wisdom within a community.
Qurʾān; Torah; Gospel; Veda; Upanishad; scripture; book; word; law; guidance; covenant; remembrance.




Line 377: Line 485:




'''Historical development'''
 
The unfolding of wisdom through time, including the revision, clarification, and expansion of prior formulations as reality becomes better known.
Unfolding; renewal; revival; ''tajdīd''; reform; development; dispensation; age; era; progression; divine pedagogy.




Line 407: Line 513:




===1) Metaphysical rationalism===
===2) Foundationalism===
===3) Epistemic parsimony===
===4) Ontological parsimony===
===5) Primacy of [[Consciousness]]===
Awareness • Inner Light • Knowing Presence • Mind • Nafs • Presence • Psyche • Rūḥ • Sentience • Shahadah • Spirit • Subjectivity • Witnessing
 
The immediate field of awareness in which experience, knowledge, doubt, perception, selfhood, and inquiry appear.
===6) Analytic idealism===
===7) Oneness of consciousness===
Monism • Nondualism
===8) Ontological priority===
===9) Gradation of consciousness===
Gradation of existence • Gradation of reality • Tashkīk al-wujūd
===10) Meta Consciousness===
Ahura Mazda • Allāh • Aten • Baha • Brahman • Dao • 'Ēl • Father • God • God the Father • Necessary Existent • Necessary Existentiator • Necessary Reality • Pure Consciousness • Shangdi • Tao • The Divine • The One • Unconditioned Reality • Vishnu • Waheguru • Wājib al-Wujūd • Yahweh
===11) Necessary simplicity===
Al-Basāṭah al-ilāhiyyah • Divine simplicity • Monotheism • Oneness • Oneness of Allah • Oneness of God • Tawhīd
===12) Absolute necessary simplicity===
===13) Conscientiation ex conscientia===
Badā'a • Creatio ex deo • Origination
===14) Necessitarianism===
ʿAdl • Divine justice
===15) Eternalism / [[Eternal Creation]]===
===16) Rule of one===
===17) First conscientiate===
First creation • First intellect • First light • Image of God • Imago dei • Mashīyya • Nūr Muhammadiyya • Ontologically first dependent existent • Pen • Perfect creation • Qalam • Universal intellect
===18) Intermediary conscientiates===
Angels • Immaterial existents • Malāʾika
===19) Observable universe===
Cosmos • Dunyā • Material dimension • Material realm • Material world • Multiverse • Natural World • Olam HaZeh • Physical world • Sensible dimension • Sensible realm • Sensible world • Universe
===20) B-theory of time===
Tenseless theory of time
===21) Compatibilism===
Divine Decree • Divine Predestination • Illusion of Libertarian Free Will • Predestination • Qadar • Soft determinism
===22) Perdurantism===
===23) Physical empiricism===
Empirical method • Scientific method
===24) [[Mindfulness]]===
Dhikr • God consciousness • Meditation • Salāh • Taqwā
===25) Self-cultivation===
===26) Superiority of intellect===
===27) Rational self-governance===
===28) Mysticism===
'Ibādah • Islām • Servitude • Submission • Worship
===29) Prayer===
Ṣalāh
===30) Fasting===
Ṣawm
===31) Charity===
Almsgiving • Zakāh
===32) Pilgrimage===
Ḥajj
===33) [[Resistance]]===
Discipline • Exertion • Fighting • Holy war • Jihād • Sacred battle • Striving • Struggle
===34) Heightened consciousness===
Altered state of consciousness • Anubhava • Enlightenment • Henosis • Ilhām • Nirvana • Noetic mystical experience • Nubuwwah • Perfect knowledge acquisition • Prophethood • Samadhi • Revelation • Wahī
===35) Gradation of Intellect===
Cognitive heterogeneity


===36) [[Local cultivation]]===
===36) [[Local cultivation]]===
Retrieved from "https://wikihikmah.org/index.php/Main_Page"