Hadīths: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
m Protected "Hadīths" ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite)) |
||
| (6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
=1) Epistemic framework= | ==1) Epistemic framework== | ||
==2) Joshua Little's 21 reasons why critical historians are skeptical of Hadīths== | |||
1) Prior probability of false ascription in religious-historical material | 1) Prior probability of false ascription in religious-historical material | ||
| Line 5: | Line 7: | ||
2) The earliest extant collections were recensions from the ninth century onwards | 2) The earliest extant collections were recensions from the ninth century onwards | ||
3) | 3) Hadīths are full of contradictions | ||
4) A large number of | 4) A large number of hadīths suspiciously look exactly like later religious sectarian, political, tribal, familial, and other partisan, polemical and apologetic creations | ||
5) | 5) Hadīths talking about later terms, later institutions, later events, and later phenomena. | ||
6) Putative supernatural explanations for texts have a vanishingly low prior probability of explaining the existence of these reports | 6) Putative supernatural explanations for texts have a vanishingly low prior probability of explaining the existence of these reports | ||
| Line 15: | Line 17: | ||
7) Reports of mass fabrication | 7) Reports of mass fabrication | ||
8) | 8) Isnāds rose relatively late, and became widespread even later | ||
9) Early usage of the word Sunnah was a generic notion of sunnah as good practice, which was not specifically Prophetical, and was independent of | 9) Early usage of the word Sunnah was a generic notion of sunnah as good practice, which was not specifically Prophetical, and was independent of hadīths | ||
10) A rapid numerical growth in | 10) A rapid numerical growth in hadīths can be observed | ||
11) Absence of | 11) Absence of hadīths in early sources | ||
12) Retrojection of | 12) Retrojection of hadīths; ratio of cited hadīths changes from mostly ascribed to followers then to companions then to the Prophet | ||
13) Various peculiar correlations, descriptions, and content that don't make sense as a product of genuine historical transmission but make more sense as a product of later debates and later ascription preferences | 13) Various peculiar correlations, descriptions, and content that don't make sense as a product of genuine historical transmission but make more sense as a product of later debates and later ascription preferences | ||
14) | 14) Hadīths contradicting earlier literary and archeological sources | ||
15) Orality means less precision in transmission | 15) Orality means less precision in transmission | ||
16) Extreme variation, early rapid mutation and distortion across the | 16) Extreme variation, early rapid mutation and distortion across the hadīth corpus | ||
17) Artificial literary or narrative elements; Recurring topoi | 17) Artificial literary or narrative elements; Recurring topoi | ||
18) | 18) Hadīths exhibit telltale signs of storyteller construction | ||
19) Exegetical reports about the context of the | 19) Exegetical reports about the context of the Qur'ān are exegesis in disguise | ||
20) Recurring disconnect between the | 20) Recurring disconnect between the hadīths and the Qur'ān in terms of historical memory | ||
21) There was no effective method for distinguishing between authentic and inauthentic | 21) There was no effective method for distinguishing between authentic and inauthentic hadīths | ||